Why always Balotelli? The rise, controversies and fading stardom of football’s great maverick

Once tipped to become one of the world’s best players, Mario Balotelli’s career has been defined by moments of extraordinary brilliance, disciplinary controversies and a succession of club moves. At…

Published 9 min read

Why always Balotelli? The rise, controversies and fading stardom of football’s great maverick

Once tipped to become one of the world’s best players, Mario Balotelli’s career has been defined by moments of extraordinary brilliance, disciplinary controversies and a succession of club moves. At 36, the former Manchester City and Italy striker is still playing football in the United Arab Emirates, alongside his brother.

Mario Balotelli has spent much of his football career attracting attention for reasons both on and off the pitch.

Celebrated for his exceptional technical ability, strength, confidence and eye for goal, the Italian striker has also become synonymous with controversy, unpredictable behaviour and a career that many believe never fully fulfilled its enormous promise.

Fifteen years after his iconic “Why always me?” celebration during Manchester City’s 6-1 demolition of Manchester United, Balotelli remains one of football’s most recognisable characters.

Now 36, the forward is playing for UAE First Division side Al-Ittifaq, where he is reunited with his biological brother, Enock Barwuah.

His journey has taken him through 13 clubs in six countries, from the early promise of Inter Milan to the Premier League, France, Turkey, Switzerland and back to Italy.

It is a career filled with trophies, memorable goals, international recognition and stories of missed opportunities.

From humble beginnings to Inter Milan stardom

Balotelli’s football journey did not begin at one of Europe’s famous youth academies.

Born Mario Barwuah in Palermo, Sicily, in 1990 to Ghanaian parents, Thomas and Rose Barwuah, he spent his early childhood in foster care with Silvia and Francesco Balotelli in Brescia.

He initially divided his time between his foster family and biological parents before being placed permanently with the Balotellis. He subsequently adopted their surname.

His footballing ability became evident at a young age. By his mid-teens, he was playing for Italian lower-league side Lumezzane, where his performances attracted attention from bigger clubs.

A trial at Barcelona did not result in a permanent move, but Inter Milan eventually secured his services in 2006.

It was at Inter that Balotelli began to establish himself as one of the most exciting young prospects in Italian football.

Under manager Roberto Mancini, who became an important mentor in his career, the teenager developed rapidly and earned opportunities in the first team.

At just 17, he contributed to Inter’s 2007-08 Serie A title triumph, scoring important goals and helping the club reach the Coppa Italia final.

His performances included a memorable brace against Juventus in the Coppa Italia semi-final, further demonstrating his ability to perform on big occasions.

However, his relationship with Inter became more complicated following the arrival of Jose Mourinho.

Mourinho relationship exposes disciplinary problems

Balotelli’s time under Mourinho was characterised by disagreements, disciplinary issues and questions about his attitude.

The Portuguese manager, known for his demanding approach to players, struggled to manage the young striker’s unpredictable behaviour.

Mourinho publicly described Balotelli as “unmanageable” and once criticised one of his performances as being close to a zero rating.

Despite the tensions, Balotelli remained part of a successful Inter side that won three Serie A titles and the UEFA Champions League during his time at the club.

But his reputation for controversy was increasingly overshadowing his achievements on the pitch.

Manchester City and the unforgettable ‘Why always me?’ moment

In August 2010, Balotelli reunited with Mancini after joining Manchester City for a reported fee of about £24 million.

The move brought him to the Premier League at a time when City were building a squad capable of challenging the traditional English football powers.

Mancini believed he could help the young forward realise his enormous potential and provide the discipline and guidance needed to control his behaviour.

Balotelli quickly became one of the most talked-about players in English football.

His time at City produced several memorable moments, but also a series of incidents that reinforced his reputation as a difficult character.

He was sent off twice during his early spell at the club and was involved in a car accident involving an Audi R8.

He also faced disciplinary scrutiny after throwing a dart at a youth-team player, an incident that highlighted concerns about his judgement.

In October 2011, firefighters were called to his Cheshire home after a firework reportedly caused a fire in his bathroom. Balotelli later said a friend had been responsible.

Just days later, however, he delivered one of the most memorable performances of his Manchester City career.

On October 23, 2011, City travelled to Old Trafford and stunned Manchester United with a 6-1 victory.

Balotelli opened the scoring before lifting his shirt to reveal the now-famous message: “Why always me?”

The celebration became an enduring image of his time in England, capturing his complicated relationship with the media and his ability to turn controversy into footballing theatre.

Balotelli scored 30 goals in 80 appearances for Manchester City, helping the club win the FA Cup in 2011 and the Premier League title in 2012.

His contribution to City’s first league championship in 44 years remains particularly significant.

Although he was sent off against Arsenal in April 2012, he returned to provide the pass for Sergio Aguero’s dramatic stoppage-time winner against Queens Park Rangers on the final day of the season.

That assist helped deliver one of the most memorable moments in Premier League history.

Mancini’s patience eventually runs out

Despite his affection for Balotelli, Mancini eventually became frustrated with the forward’s repeated disciplinary problems.

The manager had often defended him publicly and insisted that his patience was limitless, but their relationship deteriorated.

A confrontation at Manchester City’s training ground in January 2013 became a defining moment in their relationship.

Balotelli subsequently returned to Italy, joining AC Milan later that month.

Mancini described him as a talented player whose behaviour was threatening to undermine his future.

“He is not a bad guy, and a fantastic player, but I’m very sorry for him as he continues to lose his talent and his quality,” Mancini said at the time.

Former Manchester City defender Micah Richards, who played alongside Balotelli, has described him as a good person and a popular figure in the dressing room despite his unusual behaviour.

Another former team-mate, Nedum Onuoha, recalled Balotelli’s extraordinary confidence, saying the striker genuinely believed he was as good as Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo.

Although he never reached the level of those two superstars, Balotelli achieved more in football than most professional players could hope for.

Italy career reaches its peak at Euro 2012

Balotelli’s international career with Italy also produced some of the most memorable moments of his playing days.

Despite his Ghanaian heritage, he represented Italy, the country of his birth, at international level.

He became the first Black player to represent Italy at a major international tournament when he featured at Euro 2012.

The striker emerged as one of the tournament’s standout performers, scoring three goals as Italy reached the final before losing 4-0 to Spain.

His most iconic performance came in the semi-final against Germany, when he scored twice in a 2-1 victory.

His celebration after the second goal, when he removed his shirt and stood motionless with his muscles flexed, became one of the defining images of the tournament.

Balotelli finished as one of the joint top scorers at Euro 2012, sharing the Golden Boot with five other players.

However, that tournament would arguably remain the high point of his international career.

Italy’s subsequent decline and Balotelli’s inconsistent club performances limited his opportunities.

He later earned a recall under Mancini in 2018, but never established himself as a regular member of the national team again.

He finished with 36 international appearances and 14 goals, with his last Italy appearance coming in 2018.

Racism and his complicated relationship with Italy

Balotelli’s career has also been marked by repeated experiences of racial abuse.

Throughout his time in Italian football, he was subjected to racist chants and insults from sections of opposition supporters.

The abuse created a difficult relationship between the striker and some sections of the country he represented internationally.

Before Euro 2012, he warned that he would walk off the pitch if subjected to racist abuse during the tournament.

He also spoke openly about the discrimination he had experienced while playing for Inter Milan and other Italian clubs.

Despite the treatment, Balotelli continued to identify with both his Ghanaian heritage and Italian upbringing.

His story has therefore extended beyond football, reflecting wider debates about racism, identity and belonging in European sport.

Liverpool move becomes a career setback

After leaving Manchester City, Balotelli returned to AC Milan, where he initially enjoyed a productive spell.

His goals and performances suggested he could still become one of Europe’s leading strikers.

In August 2014, however, he made a surprise return to the Premier League, joining Liverpool in a deal worth approximately £16 million.

The move proved unsuccessful.

Balotelli struggled to adapt to Liverpool’s style of play and managed just one Premier League goal in 16 appearances during his first season.

He was subsequently loaned back to AC Milan, where injuries and inconsistent performances further disrupted his progress.

When he returned to Liverpool, manager Jurgen Klopp made it clear that he was not part of his plans.

Balotelli later described his transfer to Liverpool as the worst mistake of his career.

The disappointment at Anfield marked another turning point in a career increasingly characterised by short spells at different clubs.

A career across Europe and beyond

Following his Liverpool disappointment, Balotelli moved through several clubs and leagues in search of stability and a return to his best form.

He played for Nice and Marseille in France, returning to Italy with Brescia and Monza.

He also had spells with Turkish side Adana Demirspor, Swiss club Sion and Genoa, among other teams.

Although he produced flashes of his former brilliance, he struggled to maintain the consistency that had once made him one of Europe’s most exciting young forwards.

His career has now taken him to the United Arab Emirates, where he is playing for Al-Ittifaq alongside his brother Enock Barwuah.

The move represents a different chapter for a player whose earlier ambitions were firmly focused on competing at the highest level of European football.

What might have been?

Balotelli’s career remains one of football’s most fascinating stories of unfulfilled potential.

At his best, he possessed the physical strength, technical quality, finishing ability and confidence to trouble the strongest defences in Europe.

He won major trophies with Inter Milan and Manchester City, scored important goals for Italy and contributed to some of the most memorable moments in modern football.

Yet his career was repeatedly interrupted by disciplinary problems, disagreements with managers, injuries and inconsistent performances.

Former team-mates have often insisted that the public perception of Balotelli does not fully reflect the person they knew away from the pitch.

For many who watched him during his early years, the question remains whether a more disciplined and settled career could have taken him to the very top of world football.

At 36, the opportunity to fulfil those early predictions has largely passed.

But Balotelli appears to have found a different kind of satisfaction in continuing to play the game, now sharing the experience with his brother.

As Onuoha observed, finishing his career in an environment where he is happy may ultimately matter more to the striker than returning to the glamour of Europe’s biggest leagues.

For a footballer who spent much of his career asking, “Why always me?”, perhaps the final chapter is about enjoying the game on his own terms.

Share this story

Get the AfroAsia Media newsletter

The day's top stories from Africa and Asia, straight to your inbox.

Comments

0 comments

Loading…