Economist Blasts Ghana's Gold Purchase Programme as "Too Generous," Demands Small-Scale Miners Pay Tax

A prominent economic policy analyst has accused the government of giving away too much under its flagship Domestic Gold Purchase Programme, arguing that the concessions granted to gold traders and…

Published 5 min read

Economist Blasts Ghana's Gold Purchase Programme as "Too Generous," Demands Small-Scale Miners Pay Tax

A prominent economic policy analyst has accused the government of giving away too much under its flagship Domestic Gold Purchase Programme, arguing that the concessions granted to gold traders and miners are eroding badly needed tax revenue at a time when Ghana can ill afford it.

Dr. Adu Owusu Sarkodie, Executive Director of the Centre for Policy Scrutiny, said on Channel One TV's The Big Issue on Saturday that while the programme's reserve-accumulation objectives are laudable, the raft of incentives attached to it—premiums, discounts, and tax exemptions—amounts to an overly generous package that undermines fiscal mobilisation .

"We are accumulating reserves; it's too generous. There are too many giveaways, like four of them: premium, discount, tax, what again? So many things," Dr. Sarkodie said. "We can give the gold miners everything except the tax" .

The 1.5% Withholding Tax Controversy

At the heart of Dr. Sarkodie's criticism is the removal of the 1.5 per cent withholding tax on unprocessed gold winnings by small-scale miners. The exemption was introduced under the Income Tax (Amendment) Act, 2025 (Act 1134) as part of the government's broader tax reforms, intended to incentivise miners to channel their gold through official state channels rather than smuggling it abroad .

Dr. Sarkodie has previously estimated that the exemption has cost the state approximately GH¢2 billion in forgone withholding tax revenue—a figure he argues has been largely absent from public debate over the programme's costs and benefits .

"For me, I'm for revenue generation. This 1.5% withholding tax, they must pay," he said on Saturday. "I am calling on the small-scale miners to pay the 1.5% withholding tax" .

The Stakes: A Programme of Unprecedented Scale

The Domestic Gold Purchase Programme, launched by the Bank of Ghana in 2021 amid a severe foreign exchange crisis, has since grown into one of the most consequential economic interventions in Ghana's recent history. What began as a stabilisation measure during a period of depleted reserves and lost access to international capital markets has evolved into the primary channel through which Ghana's artisanal and small-scale gold output reaches the global market .

The scale is staggering. In 2026 alone, the Ghana Gold Board (GoldBod) exported 88 tonnes of gold from the small-scale sector, valued at approximately US$12 billion, according to Finance Minister Cassiel Ato Forson . Large-scale mining contributed a further 80.64 tonnes worth US$10.23 billion . The programme has been credited with supporting the cedi's stability and rebuilding Ghana's international reserves to record highs .

But the financial mechanics behind this success have drawn increasing scrutiny. The Bank of Ghana has acknowledged cumulative losses exceeding GH¢7 billion between 2022 and 2024 under the programme, driven by exchange rate differentials, the cost of purchasing gold in cedis at international benchmark prices, and operational expenses in the artisanal supply chain . An IMF report cited by critics placed the cumulative net policy cost at approximately US$1.7 billion, roughly 1.5 per cent of GDP .

GoldBod has rejected characterisations of the programme as loss-making, arguing that the figures conflate central bank monetary policy costs with the institution's own operational performance. The Board reported an operational income surplus exceeding GH¢900 million for its core activities and has since transitioned to a self-funded model, mobilising financing from commercial banks and offtakers rather than relying on the central bank .

The Galamsey Question

Beyond the fiscal concerns, Dr. Sarkodie raised a more fundamental question about the programme's sourcing: whether the gold being accumulated into Ghana's reserves is clean.

"I just hope that the gold that we are accumulating is not from galamsey," he said. "If it's from galamsey, then we are destroying the water bodies, we are destroying the environment" .

The concern is not abstract. Illegal small-scale mining, known locally as galamsey, has devastated water bodies and farmlands across Ghana's mining regions. A professor of civil and environmental engineering at the University of Cape Coast warned in November that rivers polluted by galamsey could take up to 100 years to recover, while contaminated lands might require 300 years . The Public Utilities Regulatory Commission has reported that water treatment plants are being overwhelmed by turbidity and iron levels from mining pollution, threatening safe drinking water supplies for communities .

The government has maintained that GoldBod's sourcing framework is designed to exclude illegally mined gold, and that formalising the small-scale sector through official purchasing channels is itself a strategy to reduce smuggling and improve traceability .

A Call for Comprehensive Scrutiny

Dr. Sarkodie's intervention adds to a growing chorus of voices calling for a more rigorous accounting of the programme's true costs. He has previously urged policymakers to conduct a comprehensive cost-benefit analysis that accounts not only for direct financial outlays but also forgone tax revenue, opportunity costs, and environmental impacts .

The government, for its part, has signalled that it is already tightening the programme's economics. The cost of generating foreign exchange and accumulating reserves declined from 16 per cent in 2025 to 5 per cent in 2026, and the Finance Minister has announced plans for a further 3 per cent discount on small-scale gold purchases in 2027 . GoldBod's shift to commercial financing is expected to further reduce the burden on the central bank's balance sheet .

Whether these reforms will satisfy critics like Dr. Sarkodie remains to be seen. But with Ghana's gold sector now generating tens of billions of dollars in annual export value and serving as the linchpin of the country's external stability, the question of who bears the cost—and who reaps the benefit—is unlikely to fade from public debate anytime soon.

---

Background: Ghana is Africa's largest gold producer. The Domestic Gold Purchase Programme was launched in 2021 to rebuild foreign reserves during a balance-of-payments crisis. The Ghana Gold Board (GoldBod) was established in April 2025 under Act 1140 to centralise purchasing, assaying, and export of artisanal and small-scale gold. The 1.5 per cent withholding tax on unprocessed gold was abolished under Act 1134 (2025).

Share this story

Get the AfroAsia Media newsletter

The day's top stories from Africa and Asia, straight to your inbox.

Comments

0 comments

Loading…