نعمل الآن على ترجمة هذا المقال إلى العربية — ستظهر الترجمة هنا بعد لحظات. نعرض لك في الأثناء النص الأصلي باللغة الإنجليزية.

Asante deserve more than loans of looted regalia, says Asiedu-Nketiah

The National Chairman of the National Democratic Congress (NDC), Johnson Asiedu-Nketiah, has said the Asante people deserve more than symbolic gestures in the global push for reparative justice…

بقلم

صحفي

نُشر في مدة القراءة: 7 د

Asante deserve more than loans of looted regalia, says Asiedu-Nketiah

The National Chairman of the National Democratic Congress (NDC), Johnson Asiedu-Nketiah, has said the Asante people deserve more than symbolic gestures in the global push for reparative justice, insisting that the return of looted heritage must mean full transfer of ownership and not loans.

Delivering an address on "Reparative Justice and the African Union" at the Movement for Freedom of Nations Assembly in Moscow on November 16, 2026, he used the return of Asante royal regalia to Kumasi to argue for substantive, enforceable remedies.

He pointed to the regalia now on public display at the Manhyia Palace Museum in Kumasi, noting that some objects were fully restituted while others came from British museums on loan.

"We appreciate the negotiations that made those arrangements possible, but a loan is not the same as a transfer of ownership," he said.

"That distinction matters to a community whose heritage is involved, and it reminds us that a remedy must be examined in terms of the rights restored and the obligations actually accepted."

For Asiedu-Nketiah, the Asante example exposes a wider problem in the reparations debate: gestures that look like justice but leave legal ownership, control and accountability unchanged.

The regalia and the loan

On April 9, 2024, the British Museum and the Victoria and Albert Museum (V&A) returned 32 royal objects to Ghana, 15 from the British Museum and 17 from the V&A. The British Museum's objects consist mainly of royal regalia looted from the palace in Kumasi during the Anglo-Asante wars. The arrangement was structured as a loan to sidestep UK laws that prohibit the return of cultural treasures. V&A director Tristram Hunt insisted at the time that the partnership was "not restitution by the back door," meaning it was not a way to return permanent ownership to Ghana.

The items represent only a fraction of Asante material abroad. The British Museum alone says it holds 239 items of Asante regalia. The Fowler Museum in the United States also returned seven royal artefacts to the Asantehene, bringing to 39 the number of objects at the Manhyia Palace Museum that were lost to colonial powers.

The latest: loans extended

The loans have since been extended. The gold objects on loan from the British Museum and the V&A will remain on display in Kumasi until 2030, after both institutions extended their agreements. The loans will be renewed for a further three years at the end of the current term in April 2027. The renewal followed a recent visit to Kumasi by British Museum director Nicholas Cullinan, at the invitation of the Asantehene. The announcements came in the days around Asiedu-Nketiah's address.

Separately, Ghana is set to receive around 2,000 looted artefacts from the Netherlands and Germany, in one of the largest cultural restitution efforts involving the country to date.

From Cape Coast to Kumasi

Asiedu-Nketiah, who is also Chairman of the Bureau Leadership of the African Political Parties Initiative (APPI) and a Member of the Standing Committee of the Movement for Freedom of Nations, grounded the debate in Ghana's own history.

"In Ghana, anyone who walks through Cape Coast or Elmina Castle encounters something more immediate than a chapter of history," he said.

"The buildings remain, as do records of the ships, merchants and transactions that made human captivity an international business. Behind those records were families separated, communities weakened and generations denied the freedom to shape their own lives."

He said any discussion of reparations must keep sight of those human consequences, even while dealing with the difficult questions of law and public policy.

Different injuries, different remedies

Asiedu-Nketiah argued that claims arising from enslavement, forced labour, dispossession and cultural seizure will require different remedies.

"An identifiable object calls for an inquiry into its provenance and title, while the wider history of trafficking raises questions of responsibility, applicable law and the people entitled to benefit from redress," he said.

"We should neither treat these questions as already answered nor use their complexity to postpone the work. A credible claim must rest on evidence, and a credible response must be capable of implementation."

He warned against labelling ordinary development projects as reparative justice.

"An apology, restitution, compensation, access to archives, educational measures and institutional reform may each answer a different injury. But an ordinary development project does not become reparative justice merely because it has been given a new description," he said.

"The connection between the wrong and the proposed remedy must be demonstrated, and the outcome must be open to scrutiny by those asked to accept it."

Africa's institutional work

Asiedu-Nketiah said Africa has already begun the structured work needed to turn historical claims into negotiable positions.

Following the Accra Reparations Conference of 2023, the African Union designated 2025 as the Year of Justice for Africans and People of African Descent Through Reparations and carried that commitment into its Decade of Justice and Reparations for 2026 to 2035.

Through the African Union Committee of Experts on Reparations and its Reference Group of Legal Experts, the Union is developing a Common African Position and examining legal, economic, cultural and institutional questions.

He also pointed to growing cooperation with the Caribbean, where the African Union expert mechanisms and the CARICOM Reparations Commission have begun coordinating legal analysis and diplomacy.

"Their cooperation gives the wider campaign a firmer institutional foundation," he said.

Mahama and UN Resolution 80/250

Asiedu-Nketiah recognised President John Dramani Mahama, President of Ghana and the African Union Champion on Reparations, and Ghana's leadership in securing United Nations General Assembly Resolution 80/250 on March 25, 2026.

"The 123 votes in favour gave important international recognition to the gravity of the trafficking and enslavement of Africans," he said, adding that consultations held in Accra in June had advanced the discussion.

The vote in the 193-member General Assembly was 123 in favour and 3 against, with 52 abstentions. Argentina, Israel and the United States voted against. The resolution declared the transatlantic slave trade the gravest crime against humanity. It urged reparations as a concrete step toward remedying historical wrongs. The United Kingdom was among those that abstained. Unlike Security Council resolutions, General Assembly resolutions are not legally binding, but they are an important reflection of world opinion. Ghana's foreign minister, Samuel Ablakwa, said it could pave the way for a "reparative framework."

No parallel institutions

He urged the Movement for Freedom of Nations not to create a second set of institutions alongside the African Union. The movement was initiated by Russia's United Russia party. The NDC signed a cooperation agreement with United Russia in Saint Petersburg on June 25, 2026, during a meeting of the movement's Standing Committee.

"Our members can encourage access to archives, assist dialogue with museums and public authorities, and use their relationships with governments and parliaments to support the work already being undertaken by African Union experts and CARICOM," he said.

"We would accomplish more by lending those institutions political support than by asking them to compete for attention and resources."

He added that if legislation prevents the return of cultural property, a parliament must examine it; if an agreement is reached, a government must define and honour its obligations; and if a settlement is intended to benefit an affected community, that community must have a voice in its design and a means of holding those responsible to account.

Present responsibility still matters

Asiedu-Nketiah closed by cautioning that historical injustice does not excuse present failures of governance.

"Historical injustice does not relieve [governments] of the duty to govern competently, create opportunity and account for public resources, just as the failures of present governments do not cancel legitimate claims arising from the past," he said.

"Any reparative agreement should be negotiated carefully and administered transparently, with those whose rights are at stake able to see what has been promised and whether it has been delivered."

"We have reached a point at which Africa need not merely repeat the case it has made for decades," he said. "The task now is to give that work political weight and practical assistance, and to see that recognition is followed, where responsibility can be established, by remedies that endure."

Asiedu-Nketiah is not seeking re-election as NDC National Chairman. The party's national congress is scheduled for December 19, 2026.

شارك هذا الخبر

اشترك في النشرة الإخبارية لـ AfroAsia Media

أبرز أخبار اليوم من أفريقيا وآسيا، مباشرةً إلى بريدك الإلكتروني.

التعليقات

عدد التعليقات: 0

جارٍ التحميل…